Descent

Yesterday, I returned to Afghanistan after a month in China. This is what I was thinking as our plane began its descent into Kabul. 

For days, the anticipation builds.

You think of everything that you missed while away: the city’s first real snowfall, gatherings around warm bukharis, expat holiday parties featuring traditions from around the world. You imagine your return: the chowkidor’s warm welcome when he sees you through the gate, long conversations with friends reunited, and your confidence now that you’re not just a newbie expat…

And then you are in the airport.

Airports, more alike to each other than to the cities and countries that host them, have always been a constant in your life, and in them you feel at home. But it is always in the airport – at the boarding gate – on your way back to Afghanistan that the excitement begins to mix with doubt. There’s something about those boarding areas, with their crowd of beefy western security contractors in baggy cargo pants but tight t-shirts, and slim Afghan men in shalwar kameez and Chinese sandals that you find stifling, oppressive even.

Maybe it’s the sheer amount of testosterone in the air, but you feel out of place. If you were already in country, you would be nervously adjusting your headscarf around now, but because you are not, it is still stuffed in a ball in your carry-on. You wonder if you should put it on, and then your stomach knots at the thought of covering your hair again after it has been free for so long. And so it starts. Next you find yourself repeating the questions that you’ve been asked ad nauseam by relatives and strangers and friends back home – where ever home is or was for you.

“How can you stand it over there as a woman?” 

“Why do you keep going back?”

“What do you love so much about Afghanistan?”

And, (a favorite of my father’s): “If you want to work in a harsh environment, why not just find some village in ends-of-the-earth China?”

And then, two hours later, you are flying over the snow-covered Hindu Kush.

You marvel at the beauty of those mountain peaks and ponder their meaning and history. Though its etymology is debated, Hindu Kush translates literally as “Death of the Hindu” (referring to anyone from India, i.e. Hindustan). Flying over that rugged terrain that stands sentinel over Kabul, you are struck by how much the Kush has seen and how many secrets are guarded in its valleys. And suddenly, as your plane begins its descent, you remember.

You remember the country’s complexities that you studied in undergrad and tried to make sense of on your first trip. Try to know me, it taunts. Just try. You remember the quiet peacefulness of the pre-dawn and the dusk, as well as the hectic yearning and trying and hoping and pushing of days in a post-conflict nation. You remember your firsts: first film you saw about the country (Kandahar), first impressions as you drove out of the airport in that armored vehicle on your first trip (that it’s really not so different from rural China, other than the guns and uniformed men wielding them); the first time you heard the word Afghanistan pronounced the Afghan way (Off-hahn-ee-stahn); first time you managed to find your way without getting lost; the first time you saw a potential life for yourself here…

You remember also that you are the type to fall in love more with places than with people and that sometimes – or most times – love is illogical.

The plane touches tarmac and, by then, some clarity.

You realize that, like countless faranji before you and countless that will come after, a part of you now belongs here, to this country. The reverse may never be true, but you, dostem, you belong to her.

“Year of Your Own Life”

The Chinese zodiac operates on a 12-year cycle and according to the lunar calendar. Every 12th year from the one you were born is momentous; it’s your “本命年” (literally translated: the “year of your own life”) and it can be fraught with danger, but also opportunity.

And 2012, the year of the dragon, was my ”本命年”.

As Chinese astrology predicted it would be, 2012 was huge. It was full of self-doubt (and lots of it), but also bold moves. It humbled me, inspired me, made me smile and want to cry. And I loved the good and the bad equally because both arose from my choices. 2012 confirmed my deeply independent streak, but also taught me how to truly appreciate the people in my life. 2012 also introduced me to incredible new friends and kindred spirits.

It finally brought me back to Afghanistan, something 3 years in the making, and reminded me of where my story – or at least this thread of it – began.

I’ll look back on 2012 and remember it as the year that I grew up and (cliche as it is) became the person that I was always meant to be. It was that “start of the rest of my life” that I had always waited for.

In 2012, I’ve finally stopped waiting.

And to make 2013 even better than momentous 2012, two New Year’s resolutions. Because every year is a year of your own life.

If running is more difficult, run more. This lesson applies to anything.

2013 Resolution # 1: Learn not to run from the things that I find hard . This is advice that I’ve always ignored -until now. 
Never regret

2013 resolution #2: Have faith, believe in yourself and your decisions, and never, ever regret anything. I’ve gotten much better at this in 2012, but I’ve still got a ways to go…

A Kabul Night

When it is night in the Wazir Akbar Khan neighborhood of Kabul, you forget for a moment that you are still in Afghanistan – or at least, Afghanistan as it exists today.

The streets, paved and numbered – a rarity in Kabul – are empty. Here and there a security guard stands sentinel outside of a gated house and a lone dog pads silently towards a destination unknown, its tail low and feebly wagging. For the most part, however, the streetlights cast their pale glow over nothing but the Kabul standard of dust and haze.

It is quiet in these moments after dark. Sometimes you’ll hear a peal of laughter from behind the tall walls that protect its residents – and especially its women – from the gaze of the outside world. Other times you’ll feel even more than you’ll hear the shaking of the pick-up trucks, with their load of menacing armed men in the back, as they speed past you.

For the most part, however, Wazir at night belongs to the few of us pedestrians that want it. And I, for one, want it. I relish the relative peace and privacy and, above all, the sense of normalcy - hypernormalcy, even - that it provides.

I had one of those wonderfully normal nights earlier this week, when Una and I had dinner with two of the bandmates of District Unknown, Afghanistan’s first heavy metal band. Over Lebanese food and shisha, we had somehow gotten onto the topic of our totem animals.

“If you were an animal, what would you be?” One of the guys asked.

Thus started a long and lively discusion and, even after we left the restaurant for the Wazir night, we were joking, laughing, and loudly imitating the sounds of whale and marine mammals. As Pedram was pretending – with surprising accuracy – to be a dolphin, I saw the silhouette of a private security guard, who poked his head out from behind a door at the unexpected noise. I imagined him shaking his head and chuckling at our antics, and hoped that in his dolphin-imitating, Pedram had made his night as much as he had mine.

In that moment, we were just another group of irreverent friends in another tree-lined street in another residential, semi-urban neighborhood. It could have been anywhere in the world – but it was not. It was in Kabul, as the concertina wire curling over the walls on either side reminded us.

But even in Kabul, in that sleepy little neighborhood where a deadly suicide bomb had exploded days before, there was normalcy. And normalcy = hope.

Hope that these irreverent, carefree moments and that “alternative Afghanistan” are neither so fleeting – nor, for most Afghans – so far away.

To The Crew

 

Thanksgiving in Kabul, and so much – and so many – to be thankful for. I finally feel like I am exactly where I am meant to be in life. Thank you – to new friends and old – for being a part of that. And a special thank you (bear with me for a long post – feel free to just control + f for your name):

To the colleagues that helped me get here - Toby, for having the controversial faith to give a 20 year old college student a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity; Agus (who I just saw after three years!), for making the introduction that brought me here; Tara, whose stories and experiences were what ultimately convinced me to jump on the opportunity; Ahmad, for being the facilitator that made this trip happen.

To my Twitter and other virtual buds (I do work in social media after all!) – some of whom I have yet to actually meet in person – Amandine, for trusting me to stay in your (amazingly warm and welcoming) home while you were away; Sajad, for making so many connections after numerous online interactions but just 1 in person meet-up; @_ndrw, for being a constant and supportive reader; Akhila for inspiring me with your writing; and Abed, Alex, and Mike for all of of the hours we spent working together on TEDxKabul communications.

To my family, friends, friendtors, and mentors back “home” – mom and dad for putting up with my impulsive decisions as well as the ensuing worry; Rajiv for the years of love and support – I will never forget them; Yamila, whose Egypt adventures gave me such wanderlust (and the push to create my own adventures); my old colleagues for still being so supportive (especially Will and Nathan for making me still feel part of the “team”, and AMC for the continued mentorship); Lulu (and Cadengo) for all of the pre-Afghanistan support and friendship; Lisa + Lulu collectively for reminding me of where I come from and that some things never change; Matt, for the encouragement to move forward when everyone else called me crazy; Cecilia for taking me in when I most needed it; Martin, for being the one man that’s stuck around the longest (8 years of friendship and counting!); the entire Global Shapers community for giving me a built-in and inspiring/encouraging community where ever I am; Justin for being such a great sounding board; Ted for inspiring; and Eugenia, for being the absolute best bestie a girl could ask for.

And to my new (and old) friends in Afghanistan - Farid and Zahrona for the years of friendship; Riz for making me feel so welcome during those critical first days; Gull, for helping me to feel at home for the first time in Afghanistan; Paddy for giving me a place to crash and regroup; Eliot for always making sure I was on the invite list; Melissa for being a wiser older sister and anthropology mentor; Ahmad (again) for the great conversations at FSC, Dari lessons, and shisha adventure (more to come?); Maria for being a kindred spirit in country; Pashtoon for an unforgettable experience in Kandahar; the entire Kabul rock scene (Trav, Warren, Pedram, et al) for converting me into a total, loyal groupie; and last – but definitely not least – to Hameed and Una.

Hameed, so thankful for your infinite patience and insight, for the good times we’ve already had, and all of the adventures to come. I can’t wait.

And finally to Una, for being a source of support, wisdom, and laughter since even before I arrived in country – thank you, thank you, thank you. My first two months in Afghanistan would look so different without you.

I know there’s so many people that I missed, but I think you know who you are. Thank you so much for being a part of my life. Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours! Big hugs from Kabul,

xoxo Eileen

Do insurgents fly commercial?

Packing for Kandahar. More at http://instagram.com/eileenguo

When flying from a less conservative to more conservative part of the world, there’s always that tricky question of when to don the culturally appropriate garb. Flying to Kabul isn’t too big of a deal, as the only clothing change is the addition of a headscarf. Since it’s an accessory, western women just pull it out of their purses and cover their heads before getting off the plane.

But what do you do when the attire in question is Afghan chadori, known in the west as the burqa?

You can’t whip it out of your carry-on and just throw it on with the same ease as a headscarf. The burqa requires quite a bit of adjusting for novices to get the small round skullcap to fit just right and the grids (for vision) to sit directly in front of your eyes. Even when it is on correctly, most women walk around holding the garment in place with one hand.

But let’s assume that putting on a burqa is as logistically simple as throwing on a headscarf.

There is still a more subtle cultural issue to consider. Seeing a woman sans chadori – whether niqab, hijab, or burqa – is an intimate sight usually reserved ony for husbands and close male relatives. But what if you first see a woman uncovered, and then you see her covered? Is the act of veiling itself an intimate sight? And if so, how culturally and morally taboo is it to put on a chadori under the very public gaze of passengers on a plane?

These were the questions that I was asking myself on Monday morning, as I stood in the waiting area of Kabul International Airport’s domestic terminal. The flight was delayed, with nary an announcement or explanation of any sort. I was surrounded by security contractors, scattered women – Afghan in head-to-toe black niqab and western in sweaters and headscarves – and a hundred Pashtun men in traditional salwar kameez, turbans and, in some cases, sporting long, thick beards. I was acutely aware of the number of eyes watching me (and each other); some impassively, others curiously, a small number hostilely. As I followed their eyes following me, I couldn’t help but wonder who these people were. What were they doing in Kabul, and in Kandahar? What were their stories? And, perhaps most importantly, what did they think of me?

Under those scrutinizing gazes, I almost wished that I was under the anonymizing cloak of my burqa, gifted from a friend’s wife that had no need of it in Kabul. But I just couldn’t bring myself to do it. Kabul-Kandahar is just a one hour flight, with an additional (and inevitable, or so I’m told) two hours sitting on the tarmac. Even so, I did not relish the idea of being imprisoned beneath the blue cloth the entire time.

Besides, I reasoned, though I might have been anonymous, as a woman traveling alone in chadori, I would likely have drawn more attention, not less.

But that still leaves the question of when to go beneath the burqa. Would it be worse to veil myself before the gaze of a hundred Pashtun men on the flight, or to walk, naked without it, into a throng of a hundred more in the airport?

I suppose that the answer depended on who – or what – I thought I was protecting myself against. Insurgents? The Taleban? Taleban sympathizers? The over-curious? Leering men found the world over?

And that, in turn, led to the somewhat improbable and very silly question: do insurgents fly commercial?

 

I never came up with an answer but, in the end, I veiled as soon as we landed.

Ordering the Disorder

“Europe is boring. Everyone sits around and drinks coffee and reads books all day. There’s nothing else to do. No excitement, no fun.”

K was an Arabic interpreter at the Internet Governance Forum. Originally from Lebanon, he had been working in Azerbaijan for years, with a four-year stint in Europe in-between. He was tall and slim, with a muscular grace that reminded me of a male ballerina, and he towered over me as we stood drinking cheap instant coffee. We had already covered the usual conference pleasantries, the basics of our respective personal histories, as well as our opinions on American foreign policy in Afghanistan, so we had built up a rapport when he made this pronouncement.

“Look, there are bars and clubs everywhere, but this is not what I’m talking about. Here, in Azerbaijan the driving is crazy. And you walk down the streets and see people fist-fighting and you are like, ‘Those idiots!’ but then the fight keeps your mind occupied, at least for a moment.” His hands had been stuffed in the back pockets of his jeans, and he took them out to indicate where he meant.

Here, the police are friendly. They stop your car just to get to know you. And here, if you are missing a document or something, it’s still OK. No problem. You just pay a bribe and support the man’s second job. It’s not like that in Europe.”

K betrayed the hint of a smile and I was not not sure if this was because he was joking, or if he was simply reminiscing about some encounter with the police corruption that he so euphemistically and poetically described.

“I like the excitement. The disorder. The…chaos.” He paused, as if that was not quite the word he was looking for.

And it wasn’t. I knew what he meant. It was not the chaos that he was drawn to. Not exactly. It was the grittiness, the flaws, the seeming contradictions that stared him in the face on every street corner. But it was also more than even that.

The thing that most people don’t understand about conflict and crisis zones is that even the most complex, lawless-looking places are governed by rules. Those may be utterly unintelligible to us, but they exist. And it’s the slow process of recognition, discovery, and eventual understanding of the order amidst the disorder that is so appealing.

“In Lebanon, the political situation is not so good.” K sighed and shook his head, but the shadow that crossed his face quickly dispersed. He continued on to give me a brief and simplistic history of modern Lebanon. This time, he was fully aware of the irony of his words, pulling and teasing at them to reveal the extent of the contradictions.

I mused over his love for the daily grit of life in Azerbaijan but dislike of the at times life-threatening danger of living in Lebanon.

Everyone has a limit, it seems, as to how much discomfort and danger they can tolerate.  For K, the random stresses of Azerbaijan – far “worse” than anything in Western Europe – presented an acceptable level of dark reality. It was exciting. It broke up the monotony of everyday life. The political and security situation in Lebanon, on the other hand, was too much. And understandably so; though not officially classified as a conflict zone (as Afghanistan still seems to be) the threat of violence in Beirut especially is all too real.

But perhaps even more importantly, Lebanon was his country, making it too close to make light of, too close to look at impassively and with the sense of invulnerability and invincibility that he felt in Azerbaijan. There, the danger was foreign, and the relative mundanity of its crimes and car accidents were not only bearable, but even fun.

 

A woman in a headscarf approached us. It was time for him to get back to his interpreting duties. He grimaced at me. “Let’s talk more at lunch.”

I nodded and waved, wondering idly how we were going to find each other in the masses of hungry forum attendees. But I wasn’t too worried. We had our moment of connection and I felt as if I knew everything about him, and vice versa.

In our respective Central Asian countries, we were fellow expats – and kindred spirits.

Dubai

It is morning in Dubai, and I have been up since 04:30. I watched the sun rise over a sliver of marina, the light hitting the deep turquoise of the water, the gleaming white of the yachts, and the glittering glass of the tall buildings on both sides. I’m on the 16th floor – out of about 30 – in a luxury apartment building that belongs to a friend in Kabul, and even from “down here” the views are spectacular.
I’m in Dubai for just over 24 hours to get my visa back to Afghanistan, and then I head to Baku, Azerbaijan for the UN’s Internet Governance Forum.  I didn’t expect to like Dubai. Everything about this city is the antithesis of Kabul. I love history and culture and localization and even chaos, and Dubai is modernity, efficiency, globalization, and consumerism.
That Dubai is so close to Afghanistan – and to all of the other headline-making conflicts in Africa and the Middle East – is incredibly disorienting. A short 3.5 hour flight, and you leave the endless dust and fecal-matter-coated sky of Kabul; the burqas and the distinct discomfort of being a woman; the pockmarked roads and the ditches (I fell into another one on Saturday); the crashed cars from all over the world that get a second life in the streets of Afghanistan; and the constant presence of cheap weapons and the cheap men that wield them.
 –
On the way to Kabul International Airport, I felt incredibly sad to be leaving. It was silly, since I’d be back in Afghanistan – Kandahar, to be exact – in a week. But I missed this strange place, and it did not help that I was leaving in the dark of night.
But the flight from Kabul to Dubai is always in the early morning, and so the leaving of Kabul is almost always done while the sky is still dark, the streets are empty, and your only companion is the haunting melody that floats over the mosque’s loudspeakers. That, and the armed men, though even they seem less threatening in the sleepy pre-dawn.
I regretted my last-minute decision to attend the conference in Baku. As great of an opportunity as the IGF will be, there are still so many places in Afghanistan to visit, so many people to meet, so many interviews to conduct. Besides, I had just started Dari lessons, and finally was beginning to pick up on conversations around me.
My first impression of Dubai was of the heat. I was wearing a black turtleneck sweater dress over black jeans (jeggings, to be precise), a black coat that skimmed my knees, and a blue floral headscarf that an ex-boyfriend’s mother had brought for me from Kashmir. Appropriate outfit for Kabul, not so much for muggy Dubai, where women from all over the world descended with their 4″ heels, designer bags, and tight, tight clothing. Is that cleavage, really? Her ass is hanging out of her jeans! How is this still the Middle East?
It was not until I “acclimatized” a little that I realized how much I actually missed all of this. That feeling came as I was walking through the food court of the Dubai Mall with a new friend from the Afghan Embassy, though it had been building as we drove through the new freeways past villas and skyscrapers and a remarkable amount of green space for a city that rose out of the desert.
“Do you want Pizza? KFC? Burgers?” He asked.
“I want something local,” I responded. “Is there a local fast food?”
He laughed. In a city where the population is almost 90% foreign, what could I expect? We settled on Iranian fast food that was not very fast at all. It tasted just like Afghanistan’s, though my kebab was of shrimp instead of lamb.
I feel guilty that after just a month in Afghanistan, I could want all of this. I thought I was tougher. I have always prided myself in my ability to adapt and to get off the beaten expat path. But sitting here now – in the most comfortable (and the largest!) bed I’ve slept in since leaving the U.S., in this apartment with its full wall of windows, in this city that is global in every sense of the word – part of thinks that I could get used to this.
But at the same time, I can’t shake this growing suspicion that I am just an outsider looking in, and that this world – this normal world – no longer belongs to me.

Security and Insecurity in Kabul

“From your street, go to XXXXX XXXX.  Go straight through the circle and then take the first right onto XXXX Rd. You will pass a large military compound (XXXXXXX) on your right.  The next road on the right will be blocked, but then the following road on the right will be open and unnamed. It will have a little water pump at the entrance on the right. 

Take the right onto this street and follow it to the end.  Once you reach the end, it will split, go to the right.  Follow this through the checkpoints (should be 2) straight ahead- You will probably need to do this on foot.  Once you pass through the 2nd checkpoint, go to the right and XXXX will be on your left.  There will be a gated entrance past a few barriers that you can either knock on the door or just call me and I’ll come grab you.”

[Actual directions]

It’s Thursday in Kabul, and I am speeding through the dark on my way to the “address” above. Because Friday is Afghanistan’s weekend, Thursdays are the big nights for expat socializing.

Tonight, I am starting my evening with a fellow Tufts alum and his colleagues for dinner; they are DOD contractors with DOD-contractor-security-restrictions. We had planned on meeting at the Serena, one of two luxury hotels in Kabul, but because it is right before Eid, their ops manager denied that “request for movement.”

I am more alert than usual, not because of the supposed dangers of the holiday, but because I am trying to recognize the landmarks that M, the fellow alum, mentioned in his email. The night is dark, streetlights are sporadic, and the taxi is zooming through back roads not in M’s directions.

Suddenly, the driver stops in front of a military compound. “This is it,” he indicates.

“Where’s the circle?” I ask. I feel fairly certain that I could navigate us from there, but we didn’t pass one.

The driver, a twenty-something Kabuli with bright green eyes, is impassive. I’ve driven with him before, and he always enthusiastically teaches me Dari, motivated perhaps by his lackluster English skills limited to the destinations frequented by the city’s expats.

I call M for directions and hand the phone over to the driver.

But I am nervous. We are sitting at the entrance to the military base in an off-white Corolla with the engine still running. There are American soldiers standing guard about 20 feet to our left and, surprisingly, civilian contractors walking towards the gate in front of us. I didn’t know they were even allowed to walk around.

 

When I was last in Afghanistan at the COIN Academy, military intelligence issued daily BOLO lists of suspicious activity to look out for. (BOLO stands for “Be on the lookout for”.) Men in white corollas always made the list. This was of course problematic and indicative of the vague and often inactionable intelligence the Americans collected, since half the population drove white Corollas, but that’s for another post…

I imagine how we must look to the always skittish soldiers: two Afghans sitting in a car with the engine still running; the driver speaking rapidly in Dari into a cell phone; pointing every few minutes towards the base’s front gates. All of this, of course, at the very scene of a deadly suicide attack about a month ago.

But the soldiers aren’t paying us any attention. One of them is joking with the civilian contractors; another is petting a stray dog. This is the same military that drives around the city dressed in full battle rattle with M4s/M16s in hand, looking paranoid and ridiculous surrounded by the rest of us in our beat-up old cars. I am confounded by their perspectives on security and insecurity.

 

My driver hangs up and returns my phone. “So you know where we are going?” I ask.

“No problem,” he responds, but “no problem” is the Afghan response to everything. Before I can clarify, we are off, heading in the same direction that we had come.

Five minutes, and numerous sharp turns later, we stop in front of a blocked-off road. To the right is a tiny square out-building. I can just make out half a dozen security guards with AKs crammed inside around a pot of chai and some kebabs.

One climbs over the sandbags that block the entrance, and he and my driver converse in rapid-fire Dari punctuated only by gesturing – at me, at the blocked-off street, at the car.

Finally, I am told that I must go the rest of the way alone. I peer down the road, lit by a single flood-light and surrounded by high walls and concertina wire. This must be the first of the checkpoints that M had mentioned. I don’t like the idea of walking down by myself, but the head security guard promises an escort. Not that that is necessarily any better.

I get out. I am nervous, just as I was earlier in front of the military headquarters, and that sense of unease only increases as we reach the second checkpoint, manned by two bored Afghan National Police that sit up and nudge each other when I approach. One of them looks me up and down; I hate that of all of the cultural nuances, the male once-over of a woman is universal.

I wrap my headscarf tighter around me.

“Card.” The ANP demand. I shake my head; I don’t have the CAC (common access cards) that everyone working with the military has. “Card. “ They insist.

Reluctantly, I pull out my passport and show it to them. They grab it, and I remember what  a friend once told me about never physically relinquishing passports to the ANP. We tug at it – they try to take it, I try to hold on while still allowing them to see my photo – but finally, I give in.

After what feels like ten minutes – really it couldn’t have been more than one – they return my passport and wave me through.

Another stretch of carefully watched road and I finally make it to the guardroom at the guesthouse entrance. More security here, of course, and the guard searches my bag. “Gun?” he asks.

I laugh. “What gun?” There is a strange shrillness in my voice. He laughs too, sheepish that he has to ask.

But tonight, I – my anti-NRA liberal self – wish, as I have never before wished, that I am armed.

 

I am often asked about the security situation, and my security situation, in Kabul. To the outside world, this city and country are a warzone, a perpetual trap of IEDs, suicide bombers, and firefights. And certainly, these things do exist, even in the capital.

On my second week in country, I was in a café when we heard the unmistakable sound of a firefight in our vicinity. For at least half an hour, the shots started and stopped and, most worryingly, seemed to move closer.

I was with two women that had been in Afghanistan for years, and they made light of it (on the surface at least – they also made numerous calls to try and find out more information.) Following their lead, I tried for calm as well. It wasn’t until I stood up from the table that I felt the tension that had settled into all of my limbs and the adrenaline that shook my hands.

But even in that incident, I knew that I was not in direct danger. In fact, I have never felt truly unsafe in Kabul – and the closest to fear was the night before Eid as I was heading to dinner with the contractors. Ironically, I was afraid of the very security systems meant to keep us safe.

Don’t get me wrong. I often feel uncomfortable as a woman alone in the city, sometimes lost, often with my headscarf slipping and a sliver of back or collarbone inappropriately peeking out. But there is an important distinction between insecurity and discomfort.

And so it is that when I am pretending to be Afghan and far away from the security forces – both Afghan and foreign – I feel perfectly safe in Kabul. I have no armored vehicles, no armed guards, and no movement restrictions. Instead, I depend on a network of trusted friends – especially Afghans; staying low-profile; and my own gut feelings.

But when I am confronted with security forces, my sense of security goes out the window. I feel the irrational urge to shout, “Don’t shoot, I’m an American!” – as if that is any safeguard at all. And if I feel this way, as someone that first came to Afghanistan with the U.S. military, I can only imagine the terror of the real civilians.

An Afghan Joke

Hilarity on the shores of Band-e-Amir. Photo courtesy Jawad Hamdard.

Friday is Afghanistan’s day off, and last Friday, I headed out to Band-e-Amir, Afghanistan’s first national park, with friends Gull and Jawad, and their respective families. There were 8 adults and 1 adorable infant crammed into what we call a ”面包车“ in Mandarin – bread car in English – so named because they resemble nothing more than a loaf of bread.

It was as far away as you could get from the realities of conflict, instability, and uncertainty that make up so much of the Afghanistan coverage these days. But then again, we were in Bamyan, Afghanistan’s safest province.

Our epic Afghan picnic

The day was characterized by stunningly beautiful scenery; good weather (the snow started only after we were halfway through with our epic picnic); and lots of laughter. There was the moment when we decided to squeeze 5 people into a swan-boat clearly built for 4 (“No problem, no problem! It actually fits six!”), as well as the running joke about the “Talebs” – really just traditionally dressed men enjoying their Friday off – that seemed to be following us throughout the park.

“Talebs” – just enjoying lunch, or having a serious jirga?

But my favorite was a joke told by 17-year-old Zaqi as we headed out of the park:

One day, the New Zealand PRT had lunch with some local village elders. At the end of the meal, they wanted to thank their hosts. They said, “Thank you for your great hospitality. We loved the food.”

But the interpreter was confused. Instead, he translated, “Thank you for your great food. We will build you a hospital.”

The real punchline? Zaqi concluded with: “Well, at least I think it’s a joke…”

Looking for Start-Ups in Bamiyan

The flight from Kabul to Bamiyan is brief. In 40 minutes, you soar over spurts of deep green vegetation surrounded by various shades of dusty brown; small clusters of rectangular buildings; slivers of streams that wind through the otherwise monotonous countryside; and, everywhere, mountains.

Mountains that climb higher than your small non-pressurized plane, mountains covered by nothing but golden dirt and piles of rocks, mountains that have claimed their share of human lives and crashed planes.

I arrived in Bamiyan on Sunday, in search of the province’s entrepreneurs for an upcoming documentary on start-ups in Afghanistan.

Since then, I’ve wandered through Bamiyan Center’s seemingly endless potato fields, which serve not only as sources of agricultural income, but also the area’s pedestrian highways. I spent one early morning exploring the ruins of the Bamiyan Buddhas, and another Shar’e Gholgola (or Fortress of Screams, so-named for Genghis Khan’s ruthless massacre centuries ago).I’ve smoked shisha beneath a beautifully, starry night sky and confused my own breath in front of me for the smoke of the pipe. I’ve met with members of the international community working on economic development in Bamiyan, and debated Afghan politics, Hazara identity, and predictions about 2014 with local community members. And of course, I’ve had countless cups of delicious Afghan chai.

I have not found start-ups – at least none that resemble the tech start-up model that has come to define the term in the United States.

According to Paul Graham, one of the most revered thought leaders in tech-start-up-land, start-ups are different from small businesses in their focus on a scalable product. Product-based – as opposed to service-based – is key because it means the potential to scale exponentially, and scaling is key because the very term “start-up” implies growth and scale.

In the United States, initiatives like Start-Up America promote the idea that entrepreneurship is the key to economic development and job creation, especially in a down economy.

But in Bamiyan, neither of these models seems to hold.

The local economy is still largely agrarian, with those endless potato fields producing the best tubers in all of Afghanistan. NGOs and “civil society” still play a huge role in the local social and economic fabric as well. Project funds and implementation pump millions into the local economy, providing not only jobs, but also careers for educated Bamiyanis to aspire to.

Indeed, international organizations and the local NGOs that they support seem to provide the backbone of Bamiyan. The Agha Khan Foundation, widely perceived as one of the most effective development organizations in Afghanistan today, is behind many of the economic development initiatives in Bamiyan, including eco-tourism, infrastructure projects, and small business support. UNAMA’s (United Nations Assistance Mission to Afghanistan) development unit, meanwhile, is working on basic capacity building projects for local NGOs in several key sectors. And the work of  COAM (the Conservation Organization for Afghanistan’s Mountains) seems to be as close as it gets to the Paul Graham model of start-ups; in addition to other environmental initiatives, this organization has brought to market an innovative clean stove that is not being given out, a la traditional NGOs, but traded.

This is all laudable and very important work, but it is still a far cry from the profit- and exit strategy-driven world of start-ups.

This leaves me wondering if my search for “start-ups” is Western and pitifully uninformed. Am I looking for a concept that is culturally alien to Bamiyan? Or is the lack of “start-ups” an issue of market maturity? And if that is the case, does NGO-driven economic development precede entrepreneur-driven? Or is it that my definition of start-up is too specific?

I have until Sunday to find what I’m looking for. And if I do not, it might be time to rethink some of my assumptions.

In the meantime, I’ll be enjoying the mountains, the potato fields, and the chai.